Urgent news of section
US state-run RFERL backtracks on dubious claim West was honest with Russia about NATO expansion on its borders after online outcry

US state-run RFERL backtracks on dubious claim West was honest with Russia about NATO expansion on its borders after online outcry

The article, by Mike Eckel, a senior correspondent for the state-run RFERL, drew criticism in Russia-watching circles after it was published on Wednesday. It set out to look at whether the US and its allies had given assurances to Moscow that the NATO military bloc would not expand eastwards, in an effort to avoid escalation and maintain stability in Europe.

Initially, the headline asked if Russia had been “deceived” by these promises, and thereby had a legitimate grievance when NATO signed up the former Soviet republics of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania as members. “No,” it boldly concluded, caveating, “(but it’s complicated).”

Quite how complicated the question really was would soon come back to bite RFERL, which quickly faced accusations it was glossing over a thorny issue to arrive at politically convenient conclusions.

Liviu Horovitz, a postdoctoral researcher at Brussels’ Institute for European Studies, described the article on Twitter as “excellent teaching material,” saying it served as a “prime example of how to report on a ‘debate’ so that nobody can ever guess that the ‘wrong’ side could potentially have some reasonable arguments.”

Excellent teaching material! Prime example on how to report on a "debate" so that nobody can ever guess that the "wrong" side could potentially have some reasonable arguments. https://t.co/PbiItNMB1S

Ben Aris, a former Moscow bureau reporter for Britain’s Daily Telegraph and the editor of the BNE IntelliNews business network, added that it failed to mention the work of a prominent scholar whose work on NATO expansion would have fitted less harmoniously with its argument. This, he said, “is all the evidence you need that RFERL selectively chooses evidence to push its narratives.” Other users were more generous, with Keir Giles of Britain’s state-funded Chatham House describing it as a “valiant stab at boiling down” the question.

However, the American government-run media group evidently chose to listen to its critics, and an internet archive search shows the headline was quietly updated to leave the question open-ended instead. So, to “Did the West promise Moscow that NATO would not expand?” a newly nuanced Eckel subsequently concluded, “Well, it’s complicated.”

The historical row is important, because it has defined Russia’s view on relations with the US-led military bloc. In 2017, a tranche of documents was declassified, and widely interpreted as showing that American, British, and German officials gave assurances to the Kremlin in the 1990s that NATO would not push into Eastern European nations. The result was a number of years of relative harmony, with both sides even signing a declaration maintaining they did “not consider each other as adversaries.” However, in 2004, the bloc went through the single largest expansion in its history, admitting the Baltic nations, as well as Romania, Slovakia, and Slovenia.

For many in Moscow, this was the beginning of the end for friendly ties with the West, with American troops stationed a stone’s throw from its border. It also led to a significant decline in trust, and was even cited by Russian President Vladimir Putin as a strategic threat in 2014, when the country announced it would reabsorb the Crimean Peninsula. Post-Maidan Ukraine has also since made no secret of its ambitions to join NATO, which has long been seen as a red line for Moscow, although it has received only a lukewarm response. However, some, like Eckel, continue to insist that the Kremlin was wrong to have interpreted these promises in this way, and that they were never binding.

George Kenney, a former US Foreign Service officer, sought to draw a line under that spat, commenting on the article. He said the position advanced by Washington at the time had been “a commitment, but not as iron-clad as a treaty.” However, he said, there was “no question in my mind that the US violated its promise.”

If you like this story, share it with a friend!

Source: www.rt.com

The last notes - Политика

most read news

#Политика

According to news agency RIA Novosti, Metropolitan Mitrofan, the chairman of the church’s Patriarchal Commission on Physical Culture and Sports, put Russia’s failure at Euro 2020 down to a lack of
подробнее...

Footage released online shows the woman entering the lift before the man runs after her, swinging his fists. The young couple continue to beat each other for some time, covering both their hands and
подробнее...

Former US presidential candidate Senator Mitt Romney was making news again this week, meeting with Russian opposition activist Leonid Volkov, best known for his close association with jailed activist
подробнее...

Speaking on Thursday, the deputy minister of health in Saratov, Denis Grayfer, explained that sex is “a very energy-consuming activity,” and it’s not worth the risk of increased stress after being
подробнее...

Researchers from Kiel University in Germany revealed on Wednesday that a strain of the bacterium, known as Yersina pestis, dating back millenia, had been discovered in samples taken from the remains
подробнее...

The escalations kicked off in May with the colossal DEFENDER Europe drills. That show of firepower saw 28,000 troops deployed across the continent. Now, months later, a new row has been ignited after
подробнее...

Just over 22 years ago, on 15 February 1989, the last few troops of the “Limited Contingent of Soviet Troops in Afghanistan” crossed over the Bridge of Friendship linking Afghanistan and Uzbekistan,
подробнее...

That’s according to Vladimir Voronkov, the Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations Counter-Terrorism Office and Russia’s former Permanent Representative to UN International Organizations in
подробнее...

In a letter signed by chairman Nikolay Rybakov, the leadership of the liberal Yabloko political faction, called on Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin on Thursday to change the rules and allow supplies
подробнее...

The move to give Russians a third dose comes as the country seeks to reach herd immunity in the adult population. People who have been ill with Covid-19 should also get vaccinated half a year after
подробнее...

That’s according to Moscow daily RBK, which cited two sources who revealed that the Ministry is desperately trying to avoid any possible shortage. Such situations have caused suffering and anguish in
подробнее...

A recent example has been a Twitter controversy caused by Professor Asatar Bair who has tried to make the case for, in his words, Stalin’s “successes as a leader,” in particular with respect to the
подробнее...

Vladimir Semashko, the Belarusian ambassador to Russia, explained on Monday that the pair were working towards uniting their energy and transport sectors, and would also be making plans to transition
подробнее...

The bloc’s envoy in the Belarusian caporal, Dirk Schuebel, was summoned to the foreign ministry on Monday where he was told that Minsk believes it has no other choice but to respond to EU “actions
подробнее...

The piece, by George F. Will, argued that the efforts of “civilized nations to deter” Beijing and Moscow “are starting to add up.” The headline is striking, even by today’s low, post-Russiagate
подробнее...

Videos posted online show how the road is covered in flames, with smoke causing very limited visibility. Earlier in the week, local authorities revealed that they would artificially induce rain to
подробнее...

That’s according to a source for Russian sports outlet Championat, which revealed that, at the moment, only the club’s employees have been vaccinated, with the talent refusing to be jabbed.According
подробнее...

Shadowy sources inside the country's most renowned domestic security agency, the FSB, told news site RBK on Thursday that a number of its operatives had been unable to get hold of the QR codes they
подробнее...