Urgent news of section
Western focus on Russian political dead-enders exposes failure to grasp that real change in Moscow will come from system insiders

Western focus on Russian political dead-enders exposes failure to grasp that real change in Moscow will come from system insiders

Former US presidential candidate Senator Mitt Romney was making news again this week, meeting with Russian opposition activist Leonid Volkov, best known for his close association with jailed activist Alexey Navalny.

The head-to-head has drawn flak from a range of commenters. Prominent American "Russia-watcher" Kevin Rothrock took to Twitter to ask why Volkov would want to be photographed with American politicians, given the images would likely only further undermine his credibility inside Russia. It’s as if “Volkov and others in his boat have given up on political ambitions back home,” he tweeted. 

Anti-kleptocracy work is good. Russia’s persecution of the Navalny movement is unjust. But photos like this suggest to me that Volkov and others in his boat have given up on political ambitions back home. (I don’t blame him.) https://t.co/92OxBbklwe

Indeed, posing with politicians in Washington is hardly a savvy way to make friends and influence people in Russia. But just as important is the other side of the equation: what good does it do Westerners to pose with Russian oppositionists? Romney and his ilk likely believe that by doing so they are promoting the cause of Russian liberalism. But here they run into a problem. History suggests that when liberal reform comes to Moscow, it tends not to come from the hands of liberals.

If liberalism is understood as an ideology that seeks to expand personal liberty, then its triumph can hardly be debated. Across most of the world, the majority of people now enjoy an array of legally enforceable civil, political, social, economic, and cultural rights that would have been almost unimaginable a century ago. While the extent of these rights varies greatly from country to country, it is hard to challenge the idea that they have expanded significantly over time.

Paradoxically, though, the expansion of liberty often has very little to do with liberalism itself, let alone with liberals. States grant freedoms to their citizens for a wide variety of reasons. Often these are purely pragmatic and have nothing to do with liberal ideology. Often, in fact, liberal reformers are decidedly non-liberal, doing what they are doing for decidedly illiberal reasons. Russia is a case in point.

One could well argue that Russia today is not as free as it was 10 years ago. But compared with 50, 100, or 200 years ago, it is now a land of extraordinary liberty. Yet, in all that period, liberals have only actually been in public office for two very brief periods – for a few months in 1917, and for a few years in the early 1990s. It is hard, therefore, for the country’s liberal minority to take credit for the expansion of liberty in their country.

In fact, freedom in Russia has largely been a gift handed down from above, as Tsars and General Secretaries relaxed the fetters binding their people, hoping to modernize and strengthen the state. Along the way, they’ve been aided by what one might call “enlightened bureaucrats” – state officials who have sought reform in order to make government more efficient.

It was for those reasons that, in 1762, Tsar Peter III of Russia granted the nobility freedom from their obligation of state service and, one hundred years later, Tsar Alexander II freed the serfs, created local elected assemblies, and instituting a substantial judicial reform.

Alexander’s 'Great Reforms' owed little if anything to liberalism. They were in large part a response to Russia’s defeat in the Crimean War, which revealed that substantial change in Russia’s social and economic system was necessary if the country was to modernize and be able to compete on the international scene. The result was a substantial liberalization of Russian society, carried out for fundamentally conservative reasons by bureaucrats whose primary interest was strengthening the state.

Two examples of such “enlightened bureaucrats” were the brothers Miliutin – Dmitry and Nikolai. The former carried out a wholesale reform of the Russian military, while the latter played a key role in the Editing Commission that wrote the 1861 edict emancipating Russia’s 20 million or so serfs. Nikolai made his position on change clear, stating that, “The initiative in undertaking any reforms for the good of the country belongs to the government and only to the government.”

Although the Tsar invited the Russian nobility to submit suggestions as to how to free the serfs, Miliutin and his commission ignored most of them and did things their own way. The result was not at all in line with what the more liberal members of Russian society wanted, but it had the advantage of being practical.

Much the same pattern emerges in the late Soviet Union. According to historian Robert English, the Soviet Union’s acceptance of the human rights elements of the 1975 Helsinki Final Act owed much to “midlevel diplomats - zapadniki [Westernizers] concerned to broaden the momentum of détente,” who viewed the agreement as likely “to encourage domestic reforms, a gradual liberation of the Communist system, and humanization of Soviet society.” Pressure from dissidents in the Soviet human rights movement had nothing to do with the decision.

Likewise, dissidents played next to no role in Mikhail Gorbachev’s perestroika. Rather the initiative belonged to a small group of individuals who had pursued long careers within the communist system. These included key advisers to Gorbachev such as Anatoly Chernyaev, Georgy Arbatov, Georgy Shakhnazarov, and Abel Aganbegyan.

All this suggests that Westerners who pin their hopes on the modern Russian equivalent of Soviet dissidents are likely to be wasting their time. Rather than bothering with political dead-enders like Volkov, they should be trying to discover the Miliutins and the Chernyaevs of the future. And if they’re really interested in seeing Russia become more liberal, then their concern ought to be how to make the modern-day Miliutins’ lives easier.

It’s hard to see how embarking on Cold War 2.0 does that. Kremlinologists sometimes portray Russia’s president, Vladimir Putin, as a centrist who balances competing factions within the Russian elite. Liberal bureaucrats have always been one of those factions. However, there is a widespread perception that, in the past few years, East-West tensions have caused the delicate balance of power to swing decisively in one direction, to the disadvantage of liberal Westernizers and to the advantage of their opponents.

This is to nobody’s benefit. The new Cold War atmosphere threatens enlightened bureaucracy with extinction. With this, the prospects of reform from above dwindle, leaving only one means of enacting change – revolution from below. Moscow has tried that before. It did not work out well, either for Russia or for the rest of the world.

Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!

Source: www.rt.com

The last notes - Политика

most read news

#Политика

He told the YouTube channel Solovyov Live that the terrorists’ considerable cache of weapons, and vehicles, is a massive risk for Afghanistan.“Javelins are supplied to Ukraine from the United States,”
подробнее...

Police in the Russian capital confirmed on Tuesday that they had “received a message from a woman claiming that all of the Tanuki restaurants in Moscow had been rigged to blow up. Authorities checked
подробнее...

The coronavirus was the main cause of 38,922 deaths across Russia in July, federal statistics agency Rosstat said in its monthly report.In 6,655 additional cases, the virus was listed as the suspected
подробнее...

The meeting, however, comes at the worst possible time. And it isn’t even really Ukraine’s fault. As even the staunchly pro-Maidan American-run media there have to admit, the mix of oligarchy,
подробнее...

Speaking to a journalist on YouTube, Alexey Arestovich, who works as the spokesman for Kiev's delegation to the contact group on Donbass, claimed that Ukrainians are actually the real Russians.The
подробнее...

Speaking as part of a meeting with schoolchildren on Wednesday, Putin said that the country's bloody history had hindered the growth of its population. "Here, in our nation, over the course of the
подробнее...

At last week's Army 2021 International Forum, held just outside of Moscow, a representative from the company announced that the drones are already in the sea, being put through their paces."Robots,
подробнее...

In an interview with Spanish radio station COPE on Wednesday, the head of the Catholic Church was asked his views on the chaos that has unfolded in the region since Kabul fell to the Taliban last
подробнее...

Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said on Wednesday that there appeared to be a new-found belief in Western capitals that such attempts to reshape foreign nations in their own image with open-ended
подробнее...

Citing two unnamed sources, Moscow news agency Interfax reported that Yarmysh had left for Finland. She is yet to make a statement.If confirmed, Yarmysh's move follows that of another Navalny team
подробнее...

Following the Washington encounter, Zelensky told Ukrainian TV that Biden personally gave him guarantees that America would protect Kiev’s interests.The US is ready to impose sanctions if Ukraine’s
подробнее...

The Kabul airlift began on August 14 and concluded on August 30, leaving a number of Americans – and many more Afghans who had helped them during the 20-year occupation – behind in Taliban-controlled
подробнее...

In an interview with Diplomaatia magazine published on Sunday, the leader said that the bloc was doing too little to defend itself against potential aggression."The EU meets every year and discusses
подробнее...

Azamat Ayvazov, 33, who is in a pre-trial facility in Russia's southern republic of Dagestan, gave an exclusive interview to RT's Ilya Petrenko, who became interested in the unusually talkative
подробнее...

Local media reported this week on two different adverts that appeared to be for the same Maine Coon cat springing up on the classified listings web portal. While the feline looked the same, the
подробнее...

Speaking to reporters on board his plane as he returned from a visit to Bosnia-Herzegovina on Sunday, Erdogan said defense cooperation with Russia is expanding, with the procurement of S-400 missile
подробнее...

The league table, which was updated on Monday, places the duo above the family of Andrei Guryev, an agriculture billionaire who worked for disgraced ex-oligarch Mikhail Khodorkovsky, and the relatives
подробнее...

In a statement issued over the weekend, the Moscow branch of Sushi Yobidoyobi said that the company "apologizes for hurting the feelings of the public with our photos" and said it had removed a
подробнее...